THE 15 BEST Restaurants in Wellsville, NY - With Menus, Reviews, Photos - Updated July 2024 (2024)

Customers` Favorites

“The Modern Diner is a classic, old-fashioned eatery serving up comforting meals. With a focus on customized breakfast dishes and daily specials, the diner offers a unique experience. The warm and friendly wait staff provide attentive service, making guests feel at home. The interior décor remains unchanged, adding to the nostalgic charm. Try the BLT with fries or the Pat Burger and fries for a satisfying meal.”

Customers` Favorites

“Mama's Smokin' BBQ is a must-visit destination in Western New York. The restaurant serves a range of delicious dishes, including juicy brisket and prime rib. The prime rib is especially notable, paired with a rich French onion soup. The sweet tea is perfectly balanced, and the lemon cake is superb. The atmosphere is welcoming, with good service and generous portions.”

Customers` Favorites

“L'Italia is a beautifully simple restaurant with a concise menu offering great dishes. The specials are delicious, and portions are generous. Friendly and attentive staff provide excellent service. The seafood plate and Chicago pasta are standout options, and lunch specials are a great value.”

Customers` Favorites

“Texas Hot is a highly regarded restaurant, known for its delicious food and inviting atmosphere. Customers particularly enjoy the flavorful fries and "Hots." The service is consistently commendable, with staff going the extra mile to provide a pleasant dining experience. The establishment is wheelchair accessible and kid-friendly. However, it's recommended to check on the availability of fries. The peanut butter pie is a unique offering, but may not appeal to all tastes. Dogs are allowed, making it a pet-friendly location.”

Customers` Favorites

“Wellsville General Store and Grill offers a pleasant dining experience. The food is cooked to perfection, with options like fried fish with shrimp and excellent sauces. The cafe has a cozy atmosphere with wooden tables and benches. The staff is friendly and patient, making it a great spot for families and individuals with disabilities.”

Customers` Favorites

“Napoli Pizza in Wellsville is a wonderful restaurant, known for its pristine ambiance and friendly staff, even in delivery situations. A great choice for those seeking a delightful dining experience, with staff like Josh who go the extra mile.”

“Wellsville Brewing Company is a welcoming spot with a unique atmosphere, offering a great selection of beers and delicious food, including sharable options. The friendly owners and staff provide excellent service, making it a wonderful addition to the community. With its old-world ambiance and Irish music, it's a must-visit spot, suitable for families during the day and a great spot for a night out.”

Customers` Favorites

“Las Brasas Grill Mexican Restaurant is a popular dining destination in Wellsville, offering a wide range of authentic Mexican cuisine. The restaurant is known for its generous portions and sizzling hot dishes, with customers praising the quality and freshness of the food.The menu features a variety of classic Mexican favorites, including combo platters, tacos, and specialty dishes like the tres asada tacos. Customers can choose between fried flour or corn tortillas, and the rice and beans are served in their own miniature taco salad bowls, adding a unique touch to the presentation.The restaurant's service has received mixed reviews, with some customers reporting attentive and friendly staff, while others have experienced a lack of attention, especially during slower periods. However, the overall dining experience is described as satisfactory, with the spacious and accessible dining room contributing to a comfortable atmosphere.Parking is readily available, and the restaurant is wheelchair-accessible, making it a convenient choice for a wide range of diners. Whether you're a fan of Mexican cuisine or simply looking for a hearty and satisfying meal, Las Brasas Grill Mexican Restaurant is worth a visit.”

Customers` Favorites

“Beef Haus is a welcoming restaurant that offers high-quality food at an affordable price. The service is kind, competent, and attentive, with staff members like Carrie going above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience. The atmosphere is cozy, with comfortable booths and festive decorations, making it a great spot for a birthday celebration or a quick lunch break. The menu features a range of delicious options, including sliced roast beef, beef on wick, and rack of ribs, which are highly praised by customers. With a great beer selection, wine selection, co*cktails, and desserts, there's something for everyone at Beef Haus. The restaurant's cleanliness, outdoor seating, and private room make it a great choice for all occasions.”

Customers` Favorites

“Pizza King is a family-oriented restaurant in Wellsville, known for their delicious Texas Hot and Large Cheese Light pizzas. The staff is friendly and always ready to help the community, including fundraisers for local firefighters. While some may find the service lacking in napkins and drinks, the overall experience is enjoyable with easy parking and wheelchair accessibility.”

Customers` Favorites

“I enjoy eating lunch here. Favorites are the nourish bowls. Delicious and filling. Friendly service and comfortable environment for eating in or taking out. And the chocolate chip cookies are heaven.”

Customers` Favorites

“Great atmosphere, customer service and delicious drinks!”

“The Beef House is a welcoming diner with comfortable booths and festive decorations. The prices are reasonable, and the service is quick. The restaurant serves a variety of meals, including sliced roast beef, beef on wick, and rack of ribs, which are praised as the best in the area. The menu also offers a range of options, including Delmonico steak, ribs, salmon Florentine, and more. The outdoor seating area is perfect for summer days, and the private room is ideal for special occasions. The friendly staff, including the owner, bartenders, and waitresses, provide excellent service. Overall, The Beef House is a great destination for a delicious meal.”

“The Giant Food Mart Deli offers a range of grocery items, including cooked ham, cat litter, and Purina Friskies Pate' cat food, though the selection may be limited. The deli is wheelchair-accessible, and while it may not be the top supermarket, it serves as a convenient hometown grocery store.”

Customers` Favorites

“Dragon House serves standard Chinese-American fare at an affordable price. Their menu includes dishes like Chicken chow mein, Kung Pao chicken, and Curry chicken, all made with fresh ingredients. The lunch special comes with an egg roll and fried rice. While the dining area is not upscale, the staff is friendly and the food is delivered quickly. Portion sizes are generous, allowing for multiple meals from one combo. Worth trying, especially for those who value convenience and a good price.”

“Sugar Daddy's Ice Cream-Grill offers a delightful dining experience with its extra sweet and friendly staff, who are patient and attentive to customers' needs. The place is remarkably clean, with a heavenly aroma, making it a nice treat after a long walk. However, the prices are a bit high, and the establishment can get quite crowded on hot days, leading to long wait times in the drive-thru. While the staff is not always organized, the ability to make substitutions is a plus. Overall, the restaurant provides a satisfying experience, though some improvements could be made to streamline the ordering process.”

Customers` Favorites

“Just One More is a popular spot for lunch, with a must-try cheese steak that does not disappoint. The restaurant offers a variety of options, including a kid-friendly menu with choices like the Turkey sandwich and fries. On wing nights, be prepared for a slight wait, but the delicious food and friendly staff make it worth the wait. The restaurant also serves other favorites, such as homemade chips, burgers, and salads, and maintains a clean and comfortable atmosphere.”

Customers` Favorites

“Better Days Pub & Eatery offers a relaxed atmosphere, with friendly bartenders and a variety of food options. The bacon cheeseburger is a popular choice, and the hand-cut fries with cheese are a tasty side dish. However, some reviewers have had mixed experiences with the beer, with some reporting flat tap beer and old-tasting bottled Bud Lite. The chicken wings have received mixed reviews, with some finding them overcooked and others enjoying their crispy texture. Overall, the pub has its ups and downs, but is a decent spot for a casual meal or drink.”

Customers` Favorites

“Burger King is a convenient restaurant with quick service, even for mobile orders. The staff is generally friendly and polite, with some exceptions. The food is always hot, fresh, and delicious. Vegetarian options include the popular Impossible Whopper, and the restaurant is kid-friendly and wheelchair accessible.”

Customers` Favorites

“Short's Deli on Stannards Road is a great neighborhood store with really good food. Their desserts are homemade and off the hook. The deli offers a variety of delicious subs, chicken tenders, and wings. The menu also includes paninis, although not tried by all. The deli is situated in a gas station with a big parking lot and gas pumps. It is wheelchair accessible, and the atmosphere is kid-friendly. While the food quality is excellent, some find the pricing slightly higher for party orders.”